Fifth wedding anniversary presents

The traditional 5th wedding anniversary gift is wood.

This gives you a reasonable number of gift options including:

An anniversary wine box
Plant a tree
Wooden massager
Wood puzzle (great for puzzle fiends!)
A hand carved wooden statue

Related:

First wedding anniversary presents
Twenty-fifth wedding anniversary presents

First wedding anniversary presents

The traditional 1st wedding anniversary gift is paper.

This gives you plenty of gift options including:

A scrap book
An anniversay book (e.g. a romantic novel)
A photo book
Gift vouchers
Become a laird and lady
Red letter days
Note cards
Stationery pack

Related:

Fifth wedding anniversary presents
Twenty-fifth wedding anniversary presents